A writer of horror stories is invited to a "monster club" by a mysterious old gentleman. There, three gruesome stories are told to him; between each story some musicians play their songs.
Set in the distant future, ‘I’m Gonna Kill You,’ takes place inside an ‘all gay colony’ following the journey of Cal (Cusati-Moyer) and Spector (Graceffa), two paired lovers, fighting an internal battle – where remaining colony members ultimately pay the price of their twisted games.